Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?
-
@PSX_Defector said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@scottalanmiller said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@PSX_Defector said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
And blades do not necessarily mix them together. We use exclusively software defined networking, from our switching to our firewalls. Would be the same thing without blades.
That is a port problem, you need so many ports to handle that, it kills one of the major selling points of the blades.
I only need four uplinks per chassis for the network, another four for fibre channel.. If I had 42 1U units, I would need a 48 port switch to just handle the networking, let alone the fibre channel.
No, you need two to four PER BLADE. If you do anything else, you have switching inside the blade chassis and now the chassis owner has network control and you violate the separation of duties that we were discussion above. That's the issue that HPE could not get us past. They could not come up with a way to maintain the separation between groups without replicating the entire former physical networking world.
-
@PSX_Defector said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
If I had 42 1U units, I would need a 48 port switch to just handle the networking, let alone the fibre channel.
With 42 blades, according to HPE, to keep separation of duties we needed at least 84 ports.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
how do you do that without comingling responsibilities?
Remember what I said, the interface is still old school for the actual function.
I can manage the hardware as the datacenter admin, I don't need console access to the blades nor the network/storage gear.
I can manage the hypervisor from the ESX level without ever seeing the hardware.
I can manage the switching without ever seeing ESX.
-
@PSX_Defector said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@scottalanmiller said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
how do you do that without comingling responsibilities?
Remember what I said, the interface is still old school for the actual function.
I can manage the hardware as the datacenter admin, I don't need console access to the blades nor the network/storage gear.
I can manage the hypervisor from the ESX level without ever seeing the hardware.
I can manage the switching without ever seeing ESX.
Yup, but the chassis admin gets access to everything, hence the problem. You get comingling. I get the separation that you mention without blades, as well.
-
@PSX_Defector said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
I can manage the hardware as the datacenter admin, I don't need console access to the blades nor the network/storage gear.
But can you grant access to the console to the system admins and to the switching to the network admins and give them control of the physical components of their domains without giving access to other stuff? At least on the HPE blades at the era that we had them, HPE said that you could not and made us move from switched to pass through networking to get around it.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@PSX_Defector said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
I can manage the hardware as the datacenter admin, I don't need console access to the blades nor the network/storage gear.
But can you grant access to the console to the system admins and to the switching to the network admins and give them control of the physical components of their domains without giving access to other stuff? At least on the HPE blades at the era that we had them, HPE said that you could not and made us move from switched to pass through networking to get around it.
Of course.
Big Red V, by extension Digix, had been doing that since G3 era blades. Most of it was API driven, but even if you cracked down into the interface, each blade is limited towards your permissions.
We also are talking about hosting, our guys could do anything while the customer couldn't tell what they were on. If you are talking about SOX stuff, it's just easier to split the environment. If you are talking about individual production teams, that's done via role delegation.
-
HPE didn't have that capability when we abandoned them. But for latency reasons, could have the shared network pipelines either. If you can bundle the networking together, it's not so bad.
-
Can you ask HPE if you can remove the kit list and just pick out your own that totals $60k? If its not useful to you, then what is the point.
I didn't take part in the contest as its US only. Quite often these things are US only. But, I just assumed when I quickly ready the post on SW that you 'had a budget of $60k' to buy what you want from them...Sucks to be told a list which is useless to you.
After they remove the mark up, I doubt this comes close to $60k anyway. Its probably just an order of kit they had which got cancelled so they gave away...
Pfft. If they don't let you sell it, say you are going with Dell as the free Sh*T is useless to you.
-
@Jimmy9008 said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
Can you ask HPE if you can remove the kit list and just pick out your own that totals $60k? If its not useful to you, then what is the point.
I didn't take part in the contest as its US only. Quite often these things are US only. But, I just assumed when I quickly ready the post on SW that you 'had a budget of $60k' to buy what you want from them...Sucks to be told a list which is useless to you.
After they remove the mark up, I doubt this comes close to $60k anyway. Its probably just an order of kit they had which got cancelled so they gave away...
Pfft. If they don't let you sell it, say you are going with Dell as the free Sh*T is useless to you.
The point is basically what Scott mentioned earlier - they hope you'll buy into using this gear that's almost entirely wrong for SMB and spend a ton more money on things you shouldn't but require to make this 'free' hardware work.
Another winner of this contest was telling me that they really aren't giving you this equipment (which is why you can't sell it). It's on perpetual loan at no cost to you.
-
@Jimmy9008 said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
Can you ask HPE if you can remove the kit list and just pick out your own that totals $60k? If its not useful to you, then what is the point.
I didn't take part in the contest as its US only. Quite often these things are US only. But, I just assumed when I quickly ready the post on SW that you 'had a budget of $60k' to buy what you want from them...Sucks to be told a list which is useless to you.
After they remove the mark up, I doubt this comes close to $60k anyway. Its probably just an order of kit they had which got cancelled so they gave away...
Pfft. If they don't let you sell it, say you are going with Dell as the free Sh*T is useless to you.
Yeah, they kind of acted like it was a makeover. But instead it's just dumping marketing loss leader kit that isn't useful in the SMB or on its own. Likely it's stuff that they couldn't shift or is known to generate more profit in sales than it loses by getting the customer to trigger a "sunk cost fallacy" emotional response.
Then suddenly they are buying a SAN, additional blades, etc. and HPE makes money on giving something useless away.
-
@Dashrender said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
Another winner of this contest was telling me that they really aren't giving you this equipment (which is why you can't sell it). It's on perpetual loan at no cost to you.
That's correct, it's a "demonstration loan", at least so we have heard. Otherwise you'd be screwed on taxes.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@Dashrender said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
Another winner of this contest was telling me that they really aren't giving you this equipment (which is why you can't sell it). It's on perpetual loan at no cost to you.
That's correct, it's a "demonstration loan", at least so we have heard. Otherwise you'd be screwed on taxes.
yes and No - if you paid taxes on it.. you could sell it and use the money to buy gear you wanted and pay the taxes.
-
@Dashrender said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@scottalanmiller said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@Dashrender said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
Another winner of this contest was telling me that they really aren't giving you this equipment (which is why you can't sell it). It's on perpetual loan at no cost to you.
That's correct, it's a "demonstration loan", at least so we have heard. Otherwise you'd be screwed on taxes.
yes and No - if you paid taxes on it.. you could sell it and use the money to buy gear you wanted and pay the taxes.
Maybe, but they might still have you on a contract that says that you cannot.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@Dashrender said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@scottalanmiller said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@Dashrender said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
Another winner of this contest was telling me that they really aren't giving you this equipment (which is why you can't sell it). It's on perpetual loan at no cost to you.
That's correct, it's a "demonstration loan", at least so we have heard. Otherwise you'd be screwed on taxes.
yes and No - if you paid taxes on it.. you could sell it and use the money to buy gear you wanted and pay the taxes.
Maybe, but they might still have you on a contract that says that you cannot.
sure, of course, in that case you just refuse the prize.
-
@Dashrender said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@scottalanmiller said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@Dashrender said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@scottalanmiller said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@Dashrender said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
Another winner of this contest was telling me that they really aren't giving you this equipment (which is why you can't sell it). It's on perpetual loan at no cost to you.
That's correct, it's a "demonstration loan", at least so we have heard. Otherwise you'd be screwed on taxes.
yes and No - if you paid taxes on it.. you could sell it and use the money to buy gear you wanted and pay the taxes.
Maybe, but they might still have you on a contract that says that you cannot.
sure, of course, in that case you just refuse the prize.
I'm guessing that that is the best thing to do regardless.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@Dashrender said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@scottalanmiller said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@Dashrender said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@scottalanmiller said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@Dashrender said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
Another winner of this contest was telling me that they really aren't giving you this equipment (which is why you can't sell it). It's on perpetual loan at no cost to you.
That's correct, it's a "demonstration loan", at least so we have heard. Otherwise you'd be screwed on taxes.
yes and No - if you paid taxes on it.. you could sell it and use the money to buy gear you wanted and pay the taxes.
Maybe, but they might still have you on a contract that says that you cannot.
sure, of course, in that case you just refuse the prize.
I'm guessing that that is the best thing to do regardless.
Well, if you have no lab equipment at all, and there is enough storage with it to setup at least a small lab, it could be worth it - but then again, it's power requirements might not be worth it.
-
@Dashrender said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@scottalanmiller said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@Dashrender said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@scottalanmiller said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@Dashrender said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@scottalanmiller said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
@Dashrender said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
Another winner of this contest was telling me that they really aren't giving you this equipment (which is why you can't sell it). It's on perpetual loan at no cost to you.
That's correct, it's a "demonstration loan", at least so we have heard. Otherwise you'd be screwed on taxes.
yes and No - if you paid taxes on it.. you could sell it and use the money to buy gear you wanted and pay the taxes.
Maybe, but they might still have you on a contract that says that you cannot.
sure, of course, in that case you just refuse the prize.
I'm guessing that that is the best thing to do regardless.
Well, if you have no lab equipment at all, and there is enough storage with it to setup at least a small lab, it could be worth it - but then again, it's power requirements might not be worth it.
But it doesn't have storage with it. Only works if you have a spare SAN or NAS, and if the power is worth it.
-
Not to mention the fact that the enclosure is a 10U!
-
@Shuey said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
Not to mention the fact that the enclosure is a 10U!
Yup, 10U for two little servers, and then at least 2U for the storage you will need to back end it, that's a quarter of a rack dedicated for this. You could get that down to 2U total if you weren't using blades.
-
@Jimmy9008 said in Ideas for how to use new, free gear from HPE?:
Can you ask HPE if you can remove the kit list and just pick out your own that totals $60k? If its not useful to you, then what is the point.
My understanding is that the parts list was listed ahead of time, not a surprise. So, in theory, only people for whom a blade center with some blades in it was useful would have entered. While I'm no fan of blades, @PSX_Defector is right that lots of shops use them and would like more of them. There are people for whom this would fit their business use case and they would like to win it. The issue here, I think, is that the winner turned out to be someone for whom it did not apply and now that we are examining it, it's not useful to him.
